Company Focus
3 reasons restaurant
stocks seem so delicious
Changing demographics,
new pricing power and balanced supply and demand have made restaurants among
the hottest market sectors. Here’s how you can profit from America’s dining
habits.
By Michael Brush (reprint from
MSN Money)
Terrorist attacks and a weak economy have
darkened America’s mood, but they haven’t killed its appetite. At pizza
joints, steak houses and burrito shops across the nation, we’re eating out
more than ever, judging by results at restaurant chains.
“The industry saw stronger sales in November and December as people got back
to normal routines,” says Gregory Levin, the chief financial officer of
California Pizza Kitchen (CPKI,
news,
msgs),
a popular casual dining chain. “Those patterns seem to be holding up in
2002, and that has been pleasantly surprising.”
Indeed, most of the country’s eateries have been getting robust positive
earnings-estimate revisions by analysts in the past few months, according to
IBES International, a sign that upbeat trends are likely to continue.
3 key restaurant trends...
Here’s a look at what’s behind the healthy growth in the sector, and how
investors may participate.
Going out to eat is now a way of life. The resilience of diners after Sept.
11 shows that we won’t give up the habit easily. A big reason is that many
households now have two wage earners. This means more money, but less time
for the family and cooking. Restaurants have spotted the dilemma, and
they’re capitalizing on it. That’s obvious from those
“when-you’re-here-you’re-family” commercials from Darden Restaurants (DRI,
news,
msgs)
to promote its Olive Garden chain, which, by the way, posted record sales in
the most recent quarter.
Supply and demand are back in balance. The sector binged in the mid-1990s,
when investment bankers cooked up too many new “concept” restaurants and
established players over-expanded to compete. “The number of new units in
that period was unbelievable,” says David Qualls, the chief financial
officer of Garden Fresh Restaurant (LTUS,
news,
msgs).
“I mean, people can only eat so much.” But now that binge is history -- good
news for those left standing. “The ones that survived get a bigger piece of
the pie,” says Qualls.
Restaurants are making price increases stick. Investors like this because
pricing power is so rare among companies right now. Menu prices were up 2.4%
in April, the seventh month in a row that price hikes exceeded cost
increases, says Paul Westra, who covers restaurant stocks for Robertson
Stephens.
Still, upward revisions are just a mirage, in part. Right after Sept. 11, no
one really knew how diners would react. So analysts cut their estimates too
much. Now their numbers are going back up in part to make up for lost
ground. But talk to restaurant operators and it’s clear there is still a lot
of caution behind the estimates. “Obviously we are going in the right
direction, but it is hard to predict how much business will come back this
year,” says Alan Stillman, chief executive of the upscale Smith & Wollensky (SWRG,
news,
msgs)
steak-restaurant chain. “People do not have to go out and have a steak
dinner.”
However, Robert Derrington, a restaurant analyst with Morgan Keegan, notes
that weekly data show this quarter is shaping up well so far. He thinks
sales will continue to improve as the economy gets better, and business and
tourist travel come back. “As we go through the quarter we will see more
upward revisions, and for several quarters we will see upside surprises,
especially for the restaurants that market the most effectively.”
3 tasty investment themes
So how to play this as an investor? Here are three themes.
The micro-cap fixer-uppers and expansion plays. One way to catch more upside
in a group that’s done well is to look for smaller players that are quietly
fixing problems or building on successful concepts. Positive
earnings-estimate revisions can lead the way ahead of the crowd -- because
micro-cap companies don’t have much analyst coverage.
Three possibilities are Rubio’s Restaurants (RUBO,
news,
msgs),
a fresh grilled Mexican food chain in the West; Garden Fresh Restaurants,
which operates buffet salad bars; and Smith & Wollensky.
After two years of no sales growth, Rubio’s recently decided to cut the fat
and get back to basics. The company closed 11 restaurants, put a lid on
expansion plans and came up with a plan to bring in more diners. That meant
bigger portions, a new décor and new menu items. The company is also putting
grills and see-through refrigerators out front to reinforce an emphasis on
freshness, says Jay Burnham of Rocker Partners, which has a position in
Rubio’s. The next step is more expansion, further down the road. “We slowed
the growth to focus on repositioning, and then we will ramp growth back up
once we get the concept where we want it,” says Ira Fils, Rubio’s chief
financial officer.
Like Rubio’s, the San Diego, Calif.-based Garden Fresh cut back on expansion
to focus on reversing a decline in profit margins. That meant cutting
marketing and other expenses. The company is also moving out of outlets
serving soup to get back to its strength: salad buffet bars offered under
the Souplantation and Sweet Tomatoes brand names.
Shares in the upscale Smith & Wollensky have doubled from lows of $3 earlier
this year as business bounced back. But long-term investors should see more
upside as the tiny restaurant chain replicates its formula in cities across
the country. “The attraction is that they have a highly recognized name and
the ability to grow off a small base,” says Bruce Vogenitz, a portfolio
manager at the Henlopen Fund (HENLX),
which holds shares in the company. The company has 16 restaurants, seven of
which operate under the Smith & Wollensky name. It plans to open roughly
four per year over the next four years, says Stillman. They key to
protecting the cachet of the upscale name is to limit the chain to one
restaurant per city. “We are trying to become a non-chain chain,” says
Stillman.
The hot-concept momentum plays. These are the ones that have found a recipe
that’s a huge hit, and they’re running with it. But these restaurants have
also captured the investing public’s imagination, so they have high
valuations to show for it. Prime examples include PF Chang’s China Bistro (PFCB,
news,
msgs),
Cheesecake Factory (CAKE,
news,
msgs)
and Panera Bread (PNRA,
news,
msgs),
all sporting forward price-earnings ratios in the 40 range.
Not surprisingly, this is the turf in the dining sector where that market
odd couple -- momentum investors and short sellers -- meet to do battle.
Rocker Partners, for example, is short some of these companies. “We
generally think the valuations in these stocks are ridiculous,” says
Burnham. “People get excited about high-growth concepts, but we think the
growth can’t continue and justify current prices.”
Other investment firms are cautious as well. “PF Chang is a phenomenal
operator, but we are worried about the high multiples so we have trimmed
back,” says Himali Kothari, an analyst for the John Hancock Small Cap Growth
fund (TAEMX).
Even sell-side analysts are cautious. “Unfortunately, even good companies
can stumble, so at these valuations they are not for the faint of heart,”
says Morgan Keegan’s Derrington. In short, there could be more upside as
these chains build on their successes, but you need to be careful -- or wait
for a misstep to get a better price.
The mainstream casual dining stocks with powerful brand names. They’re not
growing as fast as the “mo-mo” players above. But they’re building out
popular restaurants in the hottest area in the sector -- casual dining. It’s
growing twice as fast as any other restaurant category because it gives
customers -- often baby boomers and their families -- just what they want:
good, cheap eats ($10 to $20 per person), and decent service.
The chief examples are Applebee’s (APPB,
news,
msgs);
Darden, which operates Olive Garden and Red Lobster; Brinker International (EAT,
news,
msgs),
with its flagship Chili’s, and Ruby Tuesday. Each enjoys a large base of
restaurants that generates enough cash to support expansion. The downside:
These restaurants are trading at forward P/E’s above their growth rates. And
many are experimenting with niche dining concepts that might not pan out.
Risks
If valuations stay solid, you might see too many initial public offerings
for new chains, or follow-on offerings by popular chains, to fund more
expansion. That could lead to another bout of over-supply, just like in the
mid-1990s.
Next, keep in mind that it’s a highly competitive business, and the mighty
can fall hard when they lose out. If you buy these stocks, you have to watch
them closely. Finally, if the economy ever does show signs of bouncing back,
investors may flee this group to chase tech stocks that promise higher
growth. “I don’t believe that will happen even if tech does recover,” says
Matthew Stroud, who handles investor relations for Darden. “I think people
will want to be diversified given what has happened in the past couple of
years.”
MSN Money's editorial goal is to
provide a forum for personal finance and investment ideas. Our articles,
columns, message board posts and other features should not be construed as
investment advice, nor does their appearance imply an endorsement by
Microsoft of any specific security or trading strategy. An investor's best
course of action must be based on individual circumstances.
|
|